In Defense of Flogging
Format: PDF / Kindle (mobi) / ePub
In Defense of Flogging presents a solution both radical and simple: give criminals a choice between incarceration and the lash. Flogging is punishment: quick, cheap, and honest.
Noted criminologist Peter Moskos, in irrefutable style, shows the logic of the new system while highlighting flaws in the status quo. Flogging may be cruel, but In Defense of Flogging shows us that compared to our broken prison system, it is the lesser of two evils.
Anti-floggers in the late 1700s saw prison as a modern cure for crime. But the pro-flogging Delaware Gazette saw through this nonsense: “The Penitentiary punishment,” wrote the Gazette in 1852, “scarcely ever reforms the criminal, and we believe that it is much less efficient than our old fashioned mode of whipping and pillory.” A stated goal of the pro-prison camp was nothing less than the complete elimination of criminal punishment. In its place would be scientific treatment. One anti-flogging
the Taser as an alternative to lethal force (though many Tasers are used, somewhat worrisomely, in routine and nonthreatening issues of noncompliance), there is no acceptable mortality rate in the administration of nonlethal sentences. Punishment, including corporal punishment, is explicitly not a death sentence. Whereas electric shocks sometimes kill without any visible warning, doctors could stop a flogging if a convict shows sign of strain, such as falling unconscious. If the doctor says the
And I’m not just talking about lobster tanks. There are two live-poultry stores near me, and one even has a little “pasture” out back filled with lambs and sometimes the occasional cow. I call it the “petting zoo” because when I’m there that’s what I like to do. If I want to roast one of the lambs, I can point to one and have it dragged out of the pen to be killed, skinned, cleaned, and cut. Is it pretty? Well, not really. But at least it’s honest. And if you eat meat, this process is inevitable
of Caning. See Flogging Caldwell, Robert Graham CCA Cell blocks Chain gangs China, incarceration rate in City College of New York Cohen, Aaron Colorado, Medley case Colvin, Mark Communism, parallels with prison Community, punishment and Conducted energy devices Confinement history of solitary (see Solitary confinement) Congregate model Conover, Ted Consent, of flogged Corporal discipline Corporal punishment bans on flogging in United States establishment of penitentiary
Brunei characterization as barbaric with consent constitutionality of costs of descriptions of experience of dismantling of in United States formula for determining number of lashes guidelines for lashes administered in in Malaysia as means of restoring legitimacy to criminal justice system opposition to prison vs. public presence at rules for setting for in sharia law in Singapore torture vs. See also Whipping Florida, voting rights and felony conviction in Food,